Chicago Booth Random Walk: Interview to Luis, a baggage porter in the Andes

13 09 2009

Baggage porter in the Peruvian Andes

Baggage porter in the Peruvian Andes

In late August, I took part in a wonderful travel to Peru with some of my Chicago Booth classmates. This kind of travels organized by the Business School is called “Random Walk”.

In Peru, we hiked 45 km during 5 days along the renowned Inca Trail and we arrived on foot at Machupicchu, the lost city of the incas.

A number of local porters was helping us with our luggage in the Inca Trail. This article reproduces my conversations with one of them, whom we will call “Luis”.

“Luis: the future is tourism”

Globthink: Hola Luis!

Luis: Hola

Globthink: Where are you from?

Luis: We are from Misminay

Globthink: Ahhh, tell me about Misminay? How many inhabitants are there? What do people there do?

Luis: Well… It is a small village. A lot of people people, especially the elderly and women, work on agriculture. But men, especially the young, are now working in tourism carrying baggages in the Andes as I am doing.

Globthink: Why did people change from agriculture to tourism?

Luis: We used to be very poor. If you grow vegetables you have money once a year but if you work in tourism you have money every month.

Globthink: When did tourism start here?

Luis: Around 15 years ago more or less. We used to be much more poor before. Now it is better.

Globthink: So how much does a normal porter earn on average right now?

Luis: Around 900 Soles. That is much, much more than as a peasant.

[Globthink note: 300 USD]

Globthink: So what do you think of toursim in Machupichu and the Inca Trail?

Luis: Tourism is the future.

Globthink: Hey Luis, yesterday in the mountains, I saw children coming from School. Where is that school?

Luis: Well, it depends. Most villages do not have a school. Many children have to walk to the train station and then go to a school in a bigger village.

Globthink: But Luis, when I saw those children we were around two hours away from the station. Do you mean those children walk two hours across the mountains everyday to go to the school and two hours to come back?

Lusi: Yes

Globthink: Waaaahhhh! What do children learn in the school?

Luis: Everything: mathematics, Spanish…

Globthink: Do they also learn Quechua?

[Globthink note: Quechua is Luis' native language, the language that was spoken by the Inca before the Conquistadores arrived in the XVI century]

Luis: Yes. They do.

[Globthink note: this is true for some village school but is not the case for bigger cities like Cusco where the vehicular language is only Spanish]

Globthink: Do you think it is important that children learn Quechua?

Luis: Yes, it is. But they should also learn English, French, German… There are many tourists

Globthink: Luis, can you read?

Luis: Not much

Globthink: Changing the topic, what does the Goverment for native Peruvians in the Andes?

Luis: Not much

Globthink: But  I was told you have a now a school in Misminay. You did not have one before. Who built the school then?

Luis: The State

[Globthink note: Luis contradicts his previous statement. Obviously the debate about how much the State should intervene in native communities is a complicate one. Too much intervention may destroy local culture. Too little will leave native Peruvians poor and excluded from the society]

Globthink: So, Luis, what do native Peruvians want to do? Do they usually prefer to migrate to the cities to be “more integrated” into the Peruvian society? Or do they prefer to stay in the villages and have a “more traditional” way of living?

Luis: We want to stay in our villages

Globthink: Luis, do you know who was Che Guevera?

Luis: No

Globthink: Che Gevara was a guy who travelled a lot in Latin America. He was even here, in Machupicchu. In his travels he discovered the situation of the poor of America and decided to work for the rights of people like you. A friend of him, called Fidel Castro, and he made a revolution in Cuba. They conquered the Goverment but their revolution did not work well and degraded soon into tyranny and oppression.

Luis: Men are too greedy.

Globthink: That’s exactly want happened.

[ Luis changes the topic. He seems not interested in politics]

Luis: How is Spain?

Globthink: Spain is very different from here. Spain is very flat. Most people live in the cities. Now we have a lot of Latin Americans living in Spain. There are many Peruvians also and… well… Now it is maybe easier for immigrants in Spain because they can talk with their families on the Internet. So they may not feel nostalgic.

Luis: What is the Internet?

Globthink: Well, the Internet is just like a phone. It is just that you read instead of listening and you write instead of talking. And it is cheaper.

Luis: I see.

Globthink: Luis, coming to such a beautiful place and enjoying the landscape and fresh air of the Andes is already great. But been able of doing it with good food, tents, gas bottles, coffee in the morning and everything you and other porters carry for us is absolutely wonderful. In my name and in that of my classmates, I want to thank you for everything you are doing for us. Thank you so much.

[Globthink note: Luis smiles and looks downwards]

Luis: Thank you!

Image: the image belongs to one of the classmates who travelled with me to Peru.



5 responses

15 09 2009

Interesante, hubiera sido ideal colgar el audio! :)

15 09 2009

No tengo el audio. No se grabo nada. El post es la reconstruccion de una conversacion a partir de mis recuerdos. Next time.

18 09 2009
Fridays From The Frontline

[...] gave her first presentation, and felt it went well. Chicago Booth ‘11 GlobThink transcribed a series of conversations he had with a baggage porter in Peru. The Kellogg contingent were vocal as always. Kellogg ‘12 Jeremy talked MBA diversity and [...]

27 09 2009
Chicago Booth Random Walk: Interview to Luis, a baggage porter in the Andes | MBA Admissions dot org

[...] Visit GlobThink for more. var addthis_pub = ''; var addthis_language = 'en';var addthis_options = 'email, favorites, digg, delicious, buzz, mixx, reddit, bitly, facebook, twitter, google, more'; [...]

6 06 2011

I work in a project in Misminay… to improve the live conditions there through the vivential tourism. This project is a kind of Inclusive Business because we work with local people, and they are suppliers of tourism services and a big tour company sell those services to the tourists… now we have more families working as little companies.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.